The Rise of Values-Based Investing: An In-Depth Look at ESG

Introduction

ESG (Environmental, Social, and Governance) investing has become increasingly popular over recent years, as more investors seek to align their investments with their values and support sustainable practices. In this article, we will explore what ESG investing entails, its benefits, controversies, performance, future trends, and what sets it apart from traditional investing methods.

What is ESG?

ESG refers to three essential components that investors consider when evaluating a company for potential investment. These factors assess how well a business manages environmental risks and opportunities, social relationships with stakeholders such as employees and customers, and governance practices related to board composition, executive compensation, audits, transparency, and ethics. Companies that score high on ESG criteria are considered better positioned to address emerging global challenges like climate change, diversity & inclusion, human rights standards, data privacy concerns, and corruption prevention - all critical issues facing society today.

ESG investing is a form of responsible investing that considers environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors in addition to financial factors when making investment decisions. ESG investors aim to align their portfolios with their personal values and support companies that have a positive impact on society and the planet. ESG investing has grown rapidly in recent years, as more investors become aware of the risks and opportunities associated with ESG issues, such as climate change, human rights, diversity and corporate governance.

What are the benefits of ESG investing?

ESG investing can offer several benefits for investors, such as:

• Enhancing risk-adjusted returns: ESG factors can affect the long-term performance and sustainability of companies, as well as their reputation and stakeholder relations. By incorporating ESG criteria into their analysis, investors can identify and avoid companies that may face financial, legal or regulatory risks due to poor ESG practices. Conversely, investors can also seek out companies that have strong ESG performance and competitive advantages, such as innovation, efficiency and customer loyalty.
• Aligning with personal values: ESG investing allows investors to express their preferences and beliefs through their investment choices. By supporting companies that share their values and contribute to social and environmental goals, investors can feel more satisfied and engaged with their investments. ESG investing can also help investors avoid cognitive dissonance, which is the psychological discomfort that arises when one’s actions are inconsistent with one’s values.
• Driving positive change: ESG investing can have a positive impact on the world by influencing corporate behavior and encouraging best practices. By allocating capital to companies that adhere to high ESG standards, investors can reward them for their efforts and incentivize them to improve further. By divesting from or engaging with companies that have poor ESG performance, investors can also signal their dissatisfaction and pressure them to change.

Drivers of ESG Adoption

Several converging trends have sparked rising ESG interest:

• Climate Change - Investors recognize that environmental risks like climate change can have material financial impacts. ESG helps quantify environmental risks.
• Younger Investors - Millennial and Gen Z investors are nearly twice as likely to invest in companies targeting social or environmental goals.
• Corporate Scandals - Governance controversies at firms like Theranos and WeWork highlight the need to evaluate leadership and oversight.
• Pandemic Spotlight - COVID cast a spotlight on social issues like healthcare access, income inequality, supply chain ethics and more.
• Women Investors - Women control $40 trillion in private wealth and are more likely to factor ESG into investment decisions.
• Mission-Driven Firms - Younger companies embrace stakeholder models versus pure shareholder profit maximization.
• Greater Data - Advances in capturing ESG metrics allow for new insights into the link between sustainability and returns.

As a result of these trends, global sustainable investments reached $35.3 trillion in 2020, according to the Global Sustainable Investment Alliance. That's up 68% since 2014.

What are the controversies and challenges of ESG investing?

ESG investing is not without its controversies and challenges, such as:

• Defining and measuring ESG: There is no universally agreed-upon definition or framework for what constitutes ESG investing or how to measure it. Different investors may have different interpretations and priorities when it comes to ESG issues, which can lead to inconsistencies and confusion. Moreover, there is a lack of standardized and reliable data on ESG performance across companies and sectors, which can make it difficult to compare and evaluate them objectively.
• Balancing financial and non-financial goals: ESG investing does not necessarily mean sacrificing financial returns for non-financial outcomes. However, there may be trade-offs or conflicts between the two in some cases. For example, some ESG funds may underperform their non-ESG counterparts in certain market conditions or time periods, or some ESG issues may have negative externalities or unintended consequences for other stakeholders. Therefore, investors need to be aware of the potential risks and opportunities of ESG investing and align their expectations accordingly.
• Avoiding greenwashing and impact washing: Greenwashing is the practice of misleadingly portraying a company or a product as environmentally friendly or sustainable, while impact washing is the practice of exaggerating or fabricating the social or environmental impact of an investment. Both practices are unethical and harmful for investors and society, as they erode trust and credibility in the ESG market. To avoid falling victim to greenwashing or impact washing, investors need to conduct due diligence and verify the claims and evidence of the companies or funds they invest in.
• Navigating regulation and disclosure: The regulatory landscape for ESG investing is evolving rapidly, as more governments and authorities introduce rules and standards to promote transparency and accountability in the market. For example, the European Union has implemented the Sustainable Finance Disclosure Regulation (SFDR), which requires financial market participants to disclose information on how they integrate sustainability risks and impacts into their investment processes. While regulation can help improve the quality and comparability of ESG information, it can also pose challenges for investors in terms of compliance costs and complexity.

How does ESG investing perform?

The performance of ESG investing depends on various factors, such as the methodology, criteria, time horizon and benchmark used to evaluate it. Therefore, there is no definitive answer to whether ESG investing outperforms or underperforms non-ESG investing. The general trends and insights that can be derived from existing research and evidence is as follows:

• According to a recent Journal of Finance paper, ESG funds do not outperform non-ESG funds in terms of financial returns, but they also do not underperform them significantly. The paper analyzed the Morningstar sustainability ratings of more than 20,000 mutual funds representing over $8 trillion of investor savings.
• According to a recent European Corporate Governance Institute paper, institutional investors that signed the United Nation’s Principles of Responsible Investment (PRI) did not improve the ESG scores of their portfolio companies compared to those that did not sign the PRI. Moreover, the PRI signatories had lower financial returns and higher risk than the non-signatories. The paper compared the ESG scores of companies invested in by 684 U.S. institutional investors that signed the PRI and 6,481 institutional investors that did not sign the PRI during 2013–2017.
• According to a recent Morningstar article, ESG funds performed well in 2022 compared to their traditional counterparts, based on the analysis of nearly 8,000 European-domiciled funds across 17 categories. The article also showed that ESG funds had higher success and survivorship rates over longer time periods, indicating their resilience and quality.
• According to a recent Forbes research, ESG funds underperformed non-ESG funds in 2022, mainly due to the struggles of growth stocks such as Tesla, which are popular among ESG investors. The article also suggested that ESG funds may face more challenges when the Federal Reserve raises interest rates to combat inflation, as this could make money more expensive and reduce the attractiveness of ESG stocks.

The above research provide a mixed picture of how ESG investing performed against non-ESG investing in different contexts and periods. Therefore, it is important to be careful and critical when evaluating the performance of ESG investing, and to consider other factors besides returns, such as risk, volatility, fees and benchmarks.

Trends in ESG investing

As awareness grows among consumers, policymakers, and institutional clients alike, expect further mainstream adoption of ESG principles across asset classes worldwide. Here are a few areas gaining increased attention within the realm of responsible investing:

• Impact Investing focuses explicitly on generating measurable social impact alongside financial returns by funding projects tackling specific SDG targets directly.
• Active ownership involves engaging actively with investees via proxy voting activities, direct discussions, or filing shareholder resolutions aimed at enhancing ESG policies and execution.
• Thematic Investing centers around identifying megatrends shaping our future, such as renewables, healthcare innovation, cybersecurity, or digitalization, which offer both risks and opportunities requiring careful consideration from an ESG perspective.
• Green Bonds allow financing instruments specifically earmarked exclusively for environmental purposes (e.g., renewable energy production capacity expansion); issuance volumes continue rising rapidly year after year.
• Artificial Intelligence applications will play a pivotal role in helping analyze vast amounts of data relevant to ESG analysis, predict corporate behavior, monitor compliance, identify potential controversies earlier, and enhance overall portfolio risk management processes
• The rise of impact investing: Impact investing is a type of ESG investing that focuses on investments that generate a positive social or environmental impact. Impact investors are increasingly looking to invest in companies that are working to address climate change, promote social justice, and improve corporate governance.

• The growth of ESG ETFs and index funds: ESG ETFs and index funds offer investors a low-cost and diversified way to invest in ESG companies. ESG ETFs and index funds have grown rapidly in recent years, and are expected to continue to grow in the future.
• The increasing focus on corporate governance: Corporate governance is a key component of ESG investing. Investors are increasingly focused on investing in companies with strong corporate governance practices, such as independent boards of directors and transparent financial reporting.

Conclusion

ESG investing is a form of responsible investing that considers environmental, social and governance factors in addition to financial factors when making investment decisions. ESG investing can offer several benefits for investors, such as enhancing risk-adjusted returns, aligning with personal values and driving positive change. However, ESG investing also faces some controversies and challenges, such as defining and measuring ESG, balancing financial and non-financial goals, avoiding greenwashing and impact washing, and navigating regulation and disclosure. The performance of ESG investing depends on various factors, such as the methodology, criteria, time horizon and benchmark used to evaluate it. Therefore, there is no definitive answer to whether ESG investing outperforms or underperforms non-ESG investing. Investors need to be aware of the potential risks and opportunities of ESG investing and align their expectations accordingly.

‍